Why most of marathoncreative.co is not in Google

Pulled from the Search Console API and a full crawl, 41 pages. Not from the alert emails.

The short version

The alert emails named problems you do not have. Every technical cause I could test came back clean, and I ruled out the obvious explanations one by one rather than guessing.

15 of 41 pages are indexed. 26 are not, and the missing ones include /services/, /contact/, /about/, /portfolio/, /pricing/commercial/ and the whole who we serve set.

I also have to correct my own first guess: thin content does not explain it. The unindexed pages are about the same length as the indexed ones. What is left is a site level trust problem, which is slower and less satisfying than a tag to fix.

15indexed
19crawled, not indexed
7never discovered
37%of the site visible

What I tested and ruled out

Each of these is a common cause of exactly this symptom. None of them is happening here.

Technical head layer

clean

All 41 of 41 pages carry a canonical, a meta description, an og:image, exactly one H1, and JSON-LD structured data. Nothing is missing on any page.

robots.txt and noindex

clean

robots.txt allows everything on both the apex and www. No page carries a noindex. Every fetch Google attempted succeeded.

Duplicate content

clean

Zero duplicate titles, zero duplicate meta descriptions. I compared every page against every other page using five word shingles: no pair exceeds 55 percent similarity. Even the ten home services pages are genuinely distinct.

Redirects and the sitemap

clean

Zero of the 41 sitemap URLs redirect. The apex serves 200 with a correct canonical pointing at www. The alerts about redirects are http to https and /index.html to /, which is correct behaviour and will never stop being reported.

Site structure

clean

Every page is within two clicks of the homepage and every one of the unindexed pages is properly internally linked. There are no orphans.

Thin content

does not explain it

This is where my first guess was wrong. Indexed pages run a median of 568 words, unindexed pages 529. Nearly the same. 20 of the 26 unindexed pages are normal length, including some of the longest on the site, while 5 of the 15 indexed pages are under 300 words. Length is not what is separating them.

The 26 pages that are not indexed

20 are normal length. 6 are genuinely thin. All are internally linked and within two clicks.

PageWordsClicks from homeGoogle state
/portfolio/471never discovered
/contact/1381crawled, not indexed
/resources/how-professional-listing-photos-support-your-listing/1452crawled, not indexed
/resources/1571never discovered
/work/crunch-fitness-conroe/1701crawled, not indexed
/client-hub/2291crawled, not indexed
/services/marketing/google-ads/3402crawled, not indexed
/who-we-serve/developers/3821crawled, not indexed
/about/4061crawled, not indexed
/services/marketing/4741never discovered
/pricing/media/4811crawled, not indexed
/services/5091crawled, not indexed
/who-we-serve/builders/5261crawled, not indexed
/pricing/builders/5321crawled, not indexed
/who-we-serve/home-services/remodeling/6862crawled, not indexed
/who-we-serve/home-services/electrical/7102never discovered
/who-we-serve/home-services/concrete-foundation/7212crawled, not indexed
/who-we-serve/home-services/fencing/7262crawled, not indexed
/who-we-serve/home-services/windows-siding/7292crawled, not indexed
/who-we-serve/home-services/plumbing/7322never discovered
/who-we-serve/home-services/hvac/7552never discovered
/pricing/commercial/8041never discovered
/who-we-serve/home-services/roofing/8132crawled, not indexed
/services/brand-web/8331crawled, not indexed
/who-we-serve/home-services/8921crawled, not indexed
/who-we-serve/realtors/9521crawled, not indexed

What I recommend

Approve or mark changes on each. The last one is the one that actually matters and it is the slowest.

Rewrite /portfolio/, currently 47 words

high

Remove two dead sitemaps from Search Console

high

Request indexing on the 7 pages Google has never seen

high

Expand the 6 genuinely thin pages

med

Add real case studies under /work/

med

The real constraint: the domain has not earned enough trust yet

high

Re-measure monthly instead of reacting to each email

low

Decisions

Tap a chip on each.

What gets worked first?

Who writes the expanded copy?

The 8 home services pages are all distinct and none are indexed. Keep as is?

Set up the monthly indexation re-measure?